|
REVIEWS OF SCENARIOS IN SELF-DEFENSE VIDEOS & BOOK
|
from VIDEO
LIBRARIANCreated and hosted by 3rd degree Black Belt
holders Mary Brandl and Anita Bendickson, Scenarios In Self-Defense, is an exceptional guide to
self-defense, aimed particularly at women (but containing
useful suggestions for either sex in potentially dangerous situations). The first two
volumes Your Early Options and When An Acquaintance Becomes An Assailant
- are jam-packed with life saving
self-defense tips which dont even involve physical contact. The first tape offers advice
that is both practical and effective: set a boundary early in an ambiguous situation (with
distance, strong body language, assertive verbal language, etc.), be willing to get
attention (yell "someone call the police," not the much more vague
"help"), know what your specific course of action is going to be in a given
situation, and so on. The second tape uses many of the same principles but applies them to
"acquaintance" situations such as date rape, and sexual harassment on the job.
In the final tape, Practical Physical Resistance, Brandl and Bendickson offer
advice on the use of physical force, pointing out vital target areas on the body, and
demonstrating the most effective moves to make in a threatening situation. The Scenarios
In Self-Defense series is well-produced,
enjoyable to watch, and full of useable information presented in a logical format. Yet even when physical force is used as an option, the instructors remind
viewers that it is not used for winning, but rather for escaping.
this series is
about safety. Highly recommended.
Editors Choice.****
from LIBRARY JOURNAL
An
exceptionally well-scripted and directed series, Scenarios in Self-Defense takes the right
approach and emphasizes early intervention. The three-volume set starts with Your Early
Options, where we learn the basic themes that underlie all the advice given
thereafter: trust your feelings, set a boundary early, be willing to get attention, and
visualize. Instructors Mary Brandl and Anita Bendickson explain in detail with examples
and demonstrations what each of these ideas mean. Volume 2 takes this preventative
attitude further in When An Acquaintance Becomes An Assailant, which reemphasizes
the lessons of Volume 1 and applies them in a dating situation or harassment in the
workplace. But if you must resort to physical means, Practical Physical Resistance
teaches you the moves. Totally professional,
reality-based, straight-forward, and confident, all three
tapes direct their comments toward women, but the information could apply to men or
children as well. A fine choice for public or school libraries.
from
BOOKLIST
Two
black-belt karate experts cover self-defense tips and strategies in these two titles
sampled from a three-part series. Your Early Options tells how to initially handle
uneasy, potentially harmful encounters with strangers. Women are encourage to distance
themselves, use assertive body language, issue verbal commands, and make a scene, if
necessary. The
sincere onscreen hosts not only dispense simple advice punctuated with accounts of actual
incidents but also introduce brief, enlightening scenarios. When
An Acquaintance Becomes An Assailant presents similar guidelines for dealing with
co-workers, social acquaintances, and others who act inappropriately through physical and
verbal sexual harassment. Both well
structured videos offer excellent, workable suggestions. The third Practical Physical Resistance, introduces
last resort physical moves. Ages 16-adult.
from NCASA (NATIONAL COALITION AGAINST SEXUAL ASSAULT) NEWS
VIDEO REVIEW:
REALISTIC DEFENSES reviewed by Gloria Dialectic
At last! A well-organized, practical
self-defense course. Scenarios in
Self-Defense by Mary Brandl and Anita Bendickson offers a sensible training system
thats certain to meet the needs of most women looking for ways to reduce the risk of
personal assault. I have long been dissatisfied with the fortress mentality conveyed by
lists of self-defense rules: lock your doors, lock your car doors, walk only in
well-lighted areas, avoid apartment laundry rooms and so on. We have all been drilled in
these rules to the point of paranoia however, because the majority of rapists are
acquaintances of the victim, these prevention tips prove inadequate in many cases. Also,
they tend to isolate women, curtailing their freedom, and to imply guilt if women fail to
practice them.
On the other hand,
physical self-defense can intimidate those who have neither the time, physical ability,
nor the inclination to practice sufficiently. I have attended many a physical self-defense
class, seen self-defense moves demonstrated, and tried them with my classmates, only to
leave feeling hopeless about my ability to remember and respond under stress. Also, in my role as educator of womens
groups, I find I am given only limited time by my audiences; consequently, what I offer
must be concentrated, easily mastered, practical and memorable.
Scenarios
in Self-Defense matches these needed qualities. The set consists of three videotapes, each 35
minutes long: Your Early Options, When an Acquaintance Becomes an Assailant, and Practical
Physical Resistance. Rounding out the set is a handbook which contains information from the videos,
including diagrams of the physical self-defense moves (very important), plus pages to fill
in ones own defensive responses to common situations that may lead to attack. The handbook serves as both a handy reminder and personal
workbook for building confidence.
Because of its format, Scenarios
in Self-Defense offers flexibility to meet training needs. Each of the first two videos can be shown
separately. Each will give viewers valuable and instantly applicable techniques. The
authors see physical resistance as a last resort option; therefore, they suggest that the
third video Practical Physical Resistance, should be presented only after either
program one or two has been viewed. From a
brief, one-time presentation to a three-session course expanded with practice sessions,
Scenarios in Self-Defense provides the core content for personal safety education I have not
found elsewhere.
In
addition to flexible format, Scenarios in Self-Defense excels in presenting "middle-ground
self-defense," between prevention and physical self-defense. Starting from the premise that most assaults begins with
a seemingly harmless approach, Brandl and Bendickson teach ways to interrupt the
attackers plan by setting an unmistakable boundary early, with distance strong body
language, and assertive verbal responses. If the attacker crosses the boundary, he has
divulged his intent. The potential victim is encouraged to get attention by yelling and
making a scene. If these strategies have not thwarted the attacker,
then physical
resistance may be needed.
Repeating each instruction, showing
printed instructions on the screen and summarizing are educational techniques that make
the lessons of Scenarios easy to remember. Even the physical self-defense moves can
be made less intimidating by regarding them as answers to the questions: "What body
parts do you have free to use as weapons?" "What targets are available?"
and "How threatened do you feel?"
Im enthusiastic
about Scenarios in Self-Defense!
it
has the flexibility and the concrete workable content Ive been looking for in a
program. I applaud its feminist perspective of empowerment
rather than frightened dependence on locks or weapons as the means of self-defnese. Also,
I like its insistence on non-blame if an attack happens. All in all, its a great package. |
|